Start free trial

Home > News, Articles & Multimedia > Editorial > Licensed Board Games: Junk or Jewels?

Licensed Board Games: Junk or Jewels?

by Michael Barnes (02/04/09).

By Michael Barnes

What is a licensed board game?

Chances are you’ve seen plenty and probably played several in your time. They’re the board games festooned with characters and imagery from television shows, movies or other entertainment media. Whether it’s “Hopalong Cassidy,” “Dick Tracy,” “The Six Million Dollar Man,” “Fantasy Island,” “Pac-Man,” “Desperate Housewives” or “Disney Princesses,” licensed games have a long history as examples of cross-marketing successful properties into different entertainment formats—often for a quick cash-in on what’s momentarily hot.

Pac-Man

Pac-Man

Sadly, most of these games are completely terrible, representing little more than a crass and condescending attempt to milk a couple of extra dollars out of popular trends with little regard to building an interesting or worthwhile game around them. Most of these games are among the simplest, most basic designs possible—roll a die, move a pawn, pick up a card or spin a spinner with appropriate photographic stills or illustrations that attempt to contextualize the crude game play. But does it really make sense for four players to all represent Batman in a “Batman” board game?

Of course, some licensed games can carry significant value for collectors focused on items representing particular characters, shows or films regardless of the quality of play the games offer. But even though I am a huge fan of the films, “The Dark Crystal” and “The Nightmare before Christmas,” I know that their respective board games are total dreck in terms of game play. I do not even want them as collectibles since my gaming dollar would be better spent elsewhere.

However, over the past couple of years, hobby-market publishers, such as Fantasy Flight Games, working outside of mainstream channels have released very successful games based on current and perennially popular licenses. These include “Lord of the Rings,” the “World of Warcraft” video games and the new “Battlestar Galactica” series that are actually great games far removed from the crude game play of the licensed games of the past. I even rated “Battlestar Galactica” one of the best games that I’ve ever played. It is a masterpiece of game design that also happens to be about one of my favorite television shows.

Battlestar Galactica

Battlestar Galactica

This current crop of licensed hobby games is not only a great opportunity for fans and collectors of particular properties to extend their enjoyment of them but also represent good investment potential. Licenses will eventually expire meaning that publication of some of these games will cease.

Of these more recent licensed games, in particular titles like Avalon Hill’s “Star Wars Episode I: The Queen’s Gambit” (a much better game than you would ever imagine given the movie) and Fantasy Flight’s recently out-of-print “Marvel Heroes” game based on the exploits of Spider-Man, the X-Men and other favorite comics characters will, I believe, see significant increases in value in the coming years. “Star Wars: Epic Duels,” released by Hasbro in 2002, met with good notices in the hobby community yet was inevitably found on the clearance shelf at most retailers for as little as $5 once the marketing blitz for the second prequel film subsided. Now, secondhand copies of the game pull in between $75 and $100, and with practically no chance for a reprint, those prices will likely remain constant or increase over the next few years.

Star Wars: Epic Duels

Star Wars: Epic Duels

Licensed games are a good bet for collectability as long as you are looking at the right ones. Skip the faddish ones you see on the shelves of the major retailers, and look toward the hobby publishers for great games based on great licenses.

Remember that a licensed game from a hobby publisher might see a print run of 10,000 copies compared to the millions of copies that might circulate for a “Monopoly” game with licensed characters. And if you’re a fan of some of these properties, you might find that the biggest return on investment you’ll get from one of these games is a great evening of entertainment with friends, family and fellow enthusiasts.

WorthPoint—Discover Your Hidden Wealth

7 Responses to “Licensed Board Games: Junk or Jewels?”

  1. Cheryl says:

    I have some old games I’d like to sell them. Who buys old games?

  2. Michael Barnes Michael Barnes says:

    There are a couple of resources for selling games. One is the Marketplace at Boardgamegeek.com. I don’t recommend it because the community there is very particular about everything and there is a degree of esotericism there that is very daunting. There is a function in each game’s entry where you can see what a particular title has sold for recently.

    Ebay is an option, of course.

    There are a few second-hand places such as Troll and Toad that buy used games but they tend to be very discerning about what they buy.

    I’ve heard of some success on Craigslist with selling board games as well, but I can not personally vouch for it.

    If you have any local game/hobby shops, they may be willing to buy used games. At my store, I bought a couple of small collections to stock a used game section.

    Finally, feel free to email me with your titles and I can at least give you an idea of what they may be worth or if there is anything you have in particular demand.

  3. gary says:

    I have a milton bradley 1960 Wagon Train board game. Complete, nice box, no tears or tape marks. The box has been autographed by Robert Horton who is pictured on the cover. Have photo of Mr. Horton signing the box. Autographed obtained at the festival of the west which is held in Phx. every year in March. Any idea of value? Thanks, Gary

  4. Michael Barnes Michael Barnes says:

    Hi Gary-

    The real heartbreaker here is that the game itself, to people that play and collect board games as a hobby, isn’t likely worth very much. It’s not a game that I would pursue for either use or for my collection and I believe most other hobby gamers would feel the same way- it’s just not the kind of game that hobbyists are after.

    The value of the game is more as a piece of television memorabilia than as a board game. The value to someone who collects Wagon Train items, autographs, or is just a big fan of Robert Horton would likely be higher. The autograph is probably worth more than the game.

    Incidentally, there are two Wagon Train board games…there is another one published by Bell (1959)that I’d be willing to bet is the rarer specimen. It features B&W stills from the show.

    There is a copy of the Milton Bradley edition that you seem to have posted on Ebay right now at $50. I think that price is awfully optimistic, but the right buyer (a Wagon Train fan, likely!) might be willing to pay that price for it.

  5. Kim says:

    I have a Pepsi-Cola “The Great American Trivia Challenge” Tennessee Edition board game. I was wondering how I could tell how much it is worth? Please help!

  6. Nathan says:

    I have a 1975 “The Gambler” from Parker Brothers still in the original wrapper. Is this worth any significant amount?
    Thanks, Nathan.

  7. Maggie Turnipseed says:

    Nathan,

    Thank you for using WorthPoint!
    We found several games like yours available on the internet for sale, in various conditions. The prices asked were in the range of $12.00 to $30.00 The value of your game would be on the higher end because of the condition in the origanal wrapper.

Want a picture icon with your comment? Sign up with Gravatar to get one.

Leave a Reply