Rare, Important A. E. Crowell Decoys to Headline Decoys Unlimited Auction
The expected top lot of the Summer Decoy Auction—slated for July 28-29 by Decoys Unlimited, Inc., at the Cape Codder Resort and Hotel—is this bufflehead drake by A. E. Crowell, which carries a $125,000 to $175,000 presale estimate.
HYANNIS, Mass. – Rare and important early 20th-century decoys by the renowned carver A. E. (Elmer) Crowell, plus other highly collectible decoys, nautical items and Americana from across North America, will all come up for bid at a Summer Decoy Auction slated for July 28-29 by Decoys Unlimited, Inc., at the Cape Codder Resort and Hotel.
Around 900 lots will be offered at the Sunday-Monday sale.
“This promises to be a well-rounded auction, with something for everyone and every pocketbook,” said Ted Harmon, owner of Decoys Unlimited, Inc. “We have a large collection of decoys by Charlie Joiner from the Ballard collection, factory decoys by Stevens, Mason and Evans and, of course, the Crowells.”
One of the Crowell decoys—an early bufflehead drake, crafted circa 1910-12—carries a pre-sale estimate of $125,000 to $175,000.
“This is the rarest and finest Crowell decoy we have ever been privileged to handle,” Harmon said. “It is essentially flawless, made during Crowell’s prime and carved as a working decoy but never rigged. It basically floated on a mantle for a century.”
Amazing decorative carving of a black-bellied plover, also by A. E. Crowell, is expected to realized between $35,000 and $45,000.
It is also the highest-graded bufflehead drake by Crowell (Mass., 1862-1952) ever offered and one of only two known in this premier grade. The decoy was originally gifted by Crowell to his good friend Chester Eldridge. Eldridge’s granddaughter often played on the floor of Crowell’s workshop with Crowell’s granddaughter, Peggy Crowell, while Crowell whittled and the two men talked.
The second and third top lots in the auction are likely not to be Crowell decoys at all, but exceedingly rare hooded mergansers rendered by a member of the Hutchings family of Jones Falls, Ontario, Canada. One, a hen, is regarded by many veteran collectors as the finest example of its kind known. With a thin crest that sweeps back to a point, it should command $65,000 to $70,000.
The other is a drake, with fully extended crest and a professionally restored front bill (est. $50,000-$60,000). Both mergansers were acquired in 1896 near Chaffey’s Locks (Ontario), from James Smith, who received them by descent from his father, Henry Darling Smith. He acquired them in 1920 from Knox Williams, a local blacksmith who bought them directly from the carver.
An A. E. Crowell piece expected to generate keen bidder interest is a black-bellied plover mounted on a carved “rock” base, executed circa 1912 (est. $35,000-$45,000).
“Just when you think you’ve seen the best of the decorative works by Elmer Crowell, an amazing example like this comes along,” Harmon said. “The head, the bill and the split tail are all masterfully carved.”
This hooded merganser drake and hen by a member of the Hutchings family of Jones Falls, Ontario, may hammer for $50,000 each.
A pair of dowitcher decoys by Crowell are expected to fetch $25,000-$35,000 each. Amazingly, they had been kept in a bank safety deposit box for 50 years on the advice of the consignor’s grandfather, who predicted “they would be very valuable someday and well worth putting away.” To say he was prescient would be an understatement. Both are stunning birds.
One is a gunning model dowitcher having a split tail with raised wingtips, excellent original paint and just a few tiny shot strikes. The original bill is completely and miraculously intact. The other is a dowitcher that Crowell posed so it appears to be gazing slightly upward. It also boasts a split tail with raised wingtips, excellent original paint and a completely intact bill.
This pair of dowitchers by A. E. Crowell that had been kept in a bank safety deposit box for 50 years have a presale estimate of $25,000-$35,000 each.
One other Crowell decoy worthy of mention is a superb, early 1900s life-size woodcock (est. $25,000-$35,000). Purchased directly from the master carver himself (and signed on the base “A.E. Crowell – Cape Cod”), the decoy features dropped wingtips and a perky, upswept tail. It boasts original, thickly applied and blended paint, with wonderful painted feather detail.
An example of decoy folk art at its finest will come in the form of a pair of pintails by Lloyd Sterling (each est. $27,500-$32,000). The first is a hen pintail, quite possibly the only known pintail hen of the period by Sterling. The bird has had some restoration work done, to a thin crack in the back, the very tip of the tail, a small chip in the bill and the left base of the neck.
This hen pintail and drake pintail by Lloyd Sterling (Crisfield, Md., 1880-1964), in original paint, could gavel for $27,500 to $32,500 each.
The second is a drake, in crackled, all-original paint (like the hen), showing light overall wear that is comparable, too, to the hen’s. There are a few rubs to the age-darkened wood, most notably on the right breast. There is a tight, T-shaped crack on the back, with a small crack on the bottom and on the neck. Also, a tiny chip was reset years ago on the left edge of the tail.
Also sold will be an excellent antique carving of a sperm whale made from the pan bone, or spoon-like rear portion of the sperm whale’s jaw, the most prized part of the whale (after the teeth) to whalemen (est. $2,500-$3,500). The 29-inch carving is mounted on a newer backboard. It hung for years at the Moby Dick Restaurant (now called The Black Eddy) in Westport, Mass.
This exceptional early 1900s woodcock by A. E. Crowell, with incredible paint may find a new home for $25,000-$35,000.
Start times will be 11 a.m. (EDT) on Sunday, July 28, and 10 a.m. on Monday, July 29. Previews will be held on Saturday, July 27, from 6-9 p.m.; Sunday, July 28, from 9-11 a.m.; and Monday, July 29, from 8-10 a.m. About 300 lots will be sold July 28; the rest will be sold July 29. Internet bidding will be provided by Artfact. Phone and absentee bids will also be taken. Also, there will be a dealer and collector “overflow” sale right after Sunday’s main sale, at 4 p.m.
The Cape Codder Resort and Hotel is located at 1225 Iyannough Road in Hyannis, Mass., on Cape Cod. Decoys Unlimited has been conducting its Summer Decoy Auctions every July at the Cape Codder Resort and Hotel for several years.
For more information about this auction or to consign a single item, an estate or a collection for a future auction, call 508.362.2766; e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org or visit the Decoys Unlimited, Inc. website.
WorthPoint—Discover Your Hidden Wealth